Another Pradella West End Development

Pradella has started marketing a new development on the large parcel of land it has accumulated in West End.  This development is being promoted as Gardens Riverside West End (although it is not river front, and has a road and the Waters Edge buildings between it and the river, and it is a long walk from the main shopping and restaurant street in West End).

There appear to be many more Pradella buildings planned for this plot of land in West End.

Pradella developments

Pradella has a number of apartment developments in Brisbane that are currently being marketed.  These include:

Riverside, West End
1 bedrooms from $400,000
2 bedrooms from $540,000
3 bedrooms from $929,000
These apartments will be located behind the Waters Edge complex.  Project website.

Skyview, Kelvin Grove
1 bedrooms from $335,000
2 bedrooms from $524,000
3 bedrooms from $789,000
Settlement expected late 2014.

Canvas, South Brisbane
1 bedrooms from $346,000
2 bedrooms from $575,000
Settlement expected mid 2014.

Urban Edge, Kelvin Grove -- development completed
1 bedrooms from $429,000
2 bedrooms from $539,000

Waters Edge, West End -- development completed
2 bedrooms from $600,000
3 bedrooms from $889,000

Parklands at Sherwood - development completed
from $395,000

Waters Edge

Both towers of Waters Edge on the Brisbane River are now complete.

1, 2 and 3 bedroom apartments now selling:

• 1 bed from $499,000
• 2 bed from $549,000
• 3 bed from $899,000

You can pick up a large 3 bedroom with river views for $1.9M or a 2 bedroom with no views for $629,000. (The agent reports, in a comment below, that the two bedroom has river views. It is on level 5, and is 4 apartments back from the river front apartment. It has side views. It also has views of the commercial building next door.)

[photo of Flow on left, and the two Waters Edge buildings to the right]

The same developer, Pradella, built the Flow complex which is next door. It is always a good idea to see what resale apartments are available to compare pricing:

• Two bedroom, 4th floor, river views, 144 sqm - $995,000
• Two bedroom, lower floor, $995,000 (they are dreaming!)
• Two bedroom, rear of building, no views - $615,000 (seems too high to me)
• Two bedroom, on side of building, weird design $675,000
• Three bedroom, ground floor, 190 sqm - $1,000,000

The most recent sales in Flow were:

• Apt 81 (2 bedrooms, with river views) for $1,030,000 (which was slightly more than the off-the-plan price for this apartment).
• Apt 15 (2 bedrooms at rear) $540,000 (capital loss of $25,000 from off-the-plan sales price)
• Apt 48 for $590,000
• Apt 73 for $439,000 (capital loss of $50,000)
• Apt 65 (2 bedrooms) for $525,000 (capital loss of $115,000)
• Apt 62 (3 bedrooms) for $1,150,000

Good Size Two Bedroom Apartments in Brisbane

I have been asked recently as to which apartment buildings have good sized two bedroom apartments in inner Brisbane. Not including the super luxury apartments (such as Riparian, or Coronation Residences (169 sqm)), the following list of Brisbane apartments gives some examples of larger two bedroom apartments (all including balcony, not including car park or storage rooms):

• Flow West End, 144 sqm
• Admiralty Towers, 129 sqm
• Quay West Brisbane, 128 sqm
• Waters Edge West End, a number of designs over 120 sqm
• Saville South Bank, 120 sqm
• Metro 21, 119 sqm
• Admiralty Two, 116 sqm
• Ciana Indooroopilly, 113 sqm to 132 sqm

There are others, and I would be happy to add to this list with more examples.

Pradella

I repeat this comment from a reader, who purchased at Parklands Sherwood from Pradella, the developer. I agree.

"One has to wonder how the planning controls that regulate development could be allowed to bypass the building flood heights of 1974.

The floods came perilously close to inundation through those long dark hours of the 11/12 January 2011. The townhouses were going under the Resident Manager was knocking on the doors advising all to evacuate. We all wondered what would be the outcome.
Pradella, I wonder….. who you fed your big fat envelope to! When you were spruking to purchasers that the 1974 flood height was to the level of the swimming pool and that the complex would be built 2.5 metres above this height so that there would never be any flood risk.
I was assured when I purchased my apartment Parklands @ Sherwood from Coldwell Banker the selling Agents for Pradella Developments that the complex would not flood as it was built 2.5 metres above the 1974 flood levels. Do you think I would ever waste my money buying an apartment which was in the 1974 flood zone.
Who do you hold responsible? The Developer Pradella, The Water Board!, and/or the Brisbane City Council who aided and abetted in the development.
Why did Queensland Water allow a massive discharge of 645,000 megalitres from Wivenhoe Dam on Tuesday, at the peak of the flood crisis.
Between cleaning up and moving out on Tuesday 12 January 2011, several owners have expressed dismay that the only people that Pradella’s on site Managers addressed was their 30 or so rental Property tenants not once in their address did anyone from PRADELLA acknowledge the huge financial losses now impacting the Owners, nor the disruption to living and the associated expenses imposed as a result of water inundation.
Somebody from Pradella maybe even Mr Kim Pradella himself should explain to property owners the true flood levels and the Council should consider why the development, should have been approved!
Confused – Angry Lot Owner"

Pradella's communication (and that off their onsite managers, Central Apartments, controlled by Pradella), has been hopeless. And it seems that Pradella has a habit of buying cheap land, and then developing. Low & behold, many Pradella apartments have flooded:

Parklands Sherwood: (from the Pradella website): ""20/01/11: Whilst an amazing effort has been undertaken by Building management, Developer staff, tenants and residents, friends of tenants and residents, volunteers and emergency service staff in progressing the cleanup, much work is still required. Damage to services is still being assessed and whilst we hope power may be restored to some of the areas soon, other services and facilities will take considerable time to return to normal.:

Waters Edge (from the Pradella website): "20/01/11: Whilst significant progress has been made on the cleanup effort, the building is still without power and telecommunications due to the damage to equipment in the basement. All residents and tenants have been evacuated and quite obviously due to power issues, the building is not liveable at this point.

West End Central (from the Pradella website): "21/01/11: The clean up continues and the car park is looking better each day. We are hopeful that the repair of the electrical switchboard will commence next week. 20/01/11: Regretfully little change or positive news from what was reported earlier this week. 18/01/11: Whilst no flooding occurred in the lobby, reception pool area or apartments, the property has still been severely affected.

Encore Toowong: Flooded

Tempo West End: Flooded

Left Bank West End: Flooded

Flow West End: Mildly Flooded

Flood Building Update From Readers

212 Margaret Street still out of power, energex is talking about getting in a generator. Plus the lift shaft seems to be damaged so no go on the lifts either at the moment! No one can tell me when it will be up and running but it doesn't look good to be honest - apparently there was a lot of damage downstairs and a great deal of debris.

Riverplace Apartments maintained electrical power during the floods, so the basement carpark sustained only a few inches of water and no forced evacuation.

Admiralty Towers One - building evacuation still in force; at least 48 hours to occupancy. Lifts not working.

All services to Admiralty Quays have now been restored including all four levels of car parking in the basement.

Admiralty Two: There is still some water in the high rise lift well, and Kone cannot bring lifts into service until this water is completely drained. Owners who live in the high rise may use the low rise lifts to go to level 21, then use the fire escape to access their level. Our security guard will be on duty tonight. He has a fob for high rise owners to access level 21. Priority will be given to get at least one high rise lift operational tomorrow (Wednesday).

Water's Edge: The Developer has been working with us to clear the basements and this has nearly been completed. The cleanup in the basement should begin Tuesday 18/1/11. There is damage to the electrical boards that were located in the basement, however the repairs are expected to begin as soon as possible.

Emporium Valley: Operating normally with exception of Toulouse North Tower where power is yet to be re-instated and lift access restored. We are hopeful power will be back by Wednesday this week.

Oaks Festival Towers: Still pumping water from basement on Wednesday afternoon.

KoKo West End: Basement flooded and building evacuated

Left Bank, West End: Basement badly flooded

120 Mary Street: "Unfortunately due to flood damage the Quest River Park Central is currently closed. It is hoped to have the building back open by mid next week; however no date can be provided at this point. More information to be posted as it comes to us. "

Private property developer Mark Stockwell said the group's Riverpoint apartments at West End had water in the basement. The floodwaters did not reach the residential floors. "The water has now all been pumped out and there was some damage to the electricals, which is now being fixed."

HiDef Aerial Photos of Brisbane 2011 Floods

NearMaps took hidef aerial photographs ("photomaps") of the 2011 Brisbane floods on 13 January 2011. Some examples:

• Tennyson Reach
• Parklands Sherwood
• Regatta area
• Encore and Fresh apartments at Toowong
• Macquarie Street, St Lucia
• Waters Edge and Flow
• SL8, Tempo and LeftBank
• Vue
• SouthBank
• Admiralty precinct

Brisbane Floods

With the flood water going down, the clean up is starting. Many Brisbane apartment buildings were impacted by the floods -- basement carparks full of water and mud; no electricity; residents evacuated.

Some of the buildings that have significant water in their basements include:

• Admiralty Towers
• Admiralty Two
• Admiralty Quays "we only had minor flooding in the lower level of the basement (about 50cm deep)"
• Riverplace
• Riparian (access tunnel to carparks - carparks are above ground level)
• Felix
• 212 Margaret
• Festival Towers
• River City
• Vue at Milton
• Water's Edge
• Flow
• SL8
• Parklands Sherwood
• Fresh Toowong
• Encore Toowong
• Arbour on Grey at South Bank
• Tennyson Reach
• Most apartments on the river at St Lucia
• the list goes on

Pradella writes about Parklands at Sherwood: "Sadly this site has experienced quite a lot of damage. The Outlook – which are the entertainment facilities has been completely submerged by water. The car park under Jacaranda and Brookline is also completely submerged. Whilst floodwaters did not reach the interior of the apartment buildings, it did however breach a number of houses and townhouses. The entire complex was evacuated late on Wednesday afternoon. Power has been cut and access to the property restricted."

and about Waters Edge:

"There has been significant damage to the pool and the grounds however the water from the river has NOT entered the building. The car park under the building has flooded, and all residents evacuated. Power has been cut."

Admiralty Towers has it status (current evacuated) on its website.

I am amazed that the Council allows buildings to be built with basements that flood, forcing loss of power and residents to be evacuated. See also this article.

I am not sure how the floods will impact property prices in Queensland. After the 1974 floods, the prices of impacted houses decreased for a period. There will be a shortage of rental accommodation, as many people are looking for places to live. Foreign press is reporting on its nationals being evacuated -- see for example, this article from Singapore and Malaysia -- and QUT and UQ were flooded, which will not be good news for those trying to attract foreign students to Brisbane.

On the positive side, it could have been much worse. Only one person died in Brisbane, and the flood levels were lower than initially expected.

Aerial Photos of Brisbane

Mirvac's Newstead Waterfront project

Mirvac's Tennyson project

Pradella's Water's Edge

Kelvin Grove Urban Village

Chermside

South Bank

(photos taken September 2010)

Top End Heading Towards The Bottom

Here is evidence that, despite what real estate agents and developers tell you, the top end apartment market is not going great. Many people have overpaid in the past 4 years.

Apt 80 in Flow, at West End, now listed for $1,850,000. This is a massive 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathrooms, 4 car, riverview penthouse apartment. It is 272 sqm internal, and 370 sqm total floor space. It has been for sale for a while. It went to auction in March 2009 and did not sell. (It was purchased off-the-plan in 2006 for over $2.3M. I think a real estate agent's investment company purchased it, but am not sure. So with stamp duty and interest, a loss over well over half a million bucks!)

By comparison, Apt 23, on a lower floor (3rd floor -- partial river views) - 3 bedrooms, was listed for sale by the developer for $1.4M in November 2007.

Or the same developer, Pradella, was selling apartments off-the-plan in Waters Edge next door in May 2008 which are not as good for $1.9M to $2.2M (these are A1 and A2 apartments, 159 sqm, 3 bedrooms).

So you can see that prices being paid for expensive apartments have not held up. (Flow and Waters Edge and Riverpoint are not the greatest locations, looking west, in a semi-industrial area a long walk from any facilities. Infrastructure touted by developers 4 years ago has not arrived.)

If Flow has been a bad investment for some, what about a $4.5M capital loss. See this story.

Waters Edge Update

There are some good photos of the construction of Waters Edge on the developer's website. The developer is currently advertising an X type apartment "from $645,000". This is a one bedroom apartment, with an internal study or second bedroom (no external windows).

Ferry Road, West End

On Wednesday, 5 May 2010, the Australian Financial Review had an advertisement of page 7 for 51 Ferry Road, West End. Jones Lang LaSalle is marketing the property for sale, as a 6,381 sqm riverfront site, with major development potential. Expressions of interest closing 3 June.

This would be a worry for purchasers in Waters Edge, because this is the neighbouring site, and many of the apartments look directly into this site. It may also impact the cheap apartments built on Ferry Road.

Promised Infrastructure

I often visit off-the-plan sales offices for apartment projects, and I am often told about planned infrastructure. A new pedestrian bridge, or a new CityCat ferry stop, or a new bus route, or a new supermarket planned for a neighbouring or nearby site, or restaurants about to open. I go back a number of years later, and the planned infrastructure is still not there.

Sales agents often talk about stuff that will improve the area but that never actually eventuates. So be careful about such "promises". It is best to look at what the area is like now, because this is how the area may look for some time to come. Do not pay extra for future benefits that may never arrive. If they do arrive, then you will get some capital appreciation.

I walked around West End last night. A Saturday night. Boundary Street was alive and hoping. South Bank was busy and bustling. Montague Road was dead. It was dark and no people were around. Nothing was open. It is still a scary semi-industrial area. So be careful if buying into Flow, or Waters Edge, or Koko or Riverpoint. There is a lack of public transport, and it is a very isolated area. I would not walk home from the city at night to Flow or Riverpoint. The promises made by sales agents to me a number of years ago (new park, CityCat terminal, new coffee shops and restaurants opening, a new supermarket on Montague Road, a new bus route with regular buses for all the new residents) just did not eventuate. Still many light industrial uses and sheds for spray painters.

NearMaps

Here are some great recent photos from NearMaps of various Brisbane apartment complexes:

• Fresh Toowong & Encore Toowong
• Parklands Sherwood
• Tennyson Reach
• Admiralty Precinct, including Meriton's new development (and here too)
• Newstead River Park
• Hamilton Portside
• Water's Edge site, Flow and Riverpoint
• South Bank, Arbour on Grey

Charlotte Towers, Festival Towers, Felix, Sebel Brisbane: here

New Apartment Developments in Brisbane

There are very few new apartment developments in inner city Brisbane under construction and nearing completion. This is good news for owners of existing apartments, as the number of apartments available for sale will not increase dramatically in the next few years. This is my list:

• Evolution - completed last year, overpriced, developer trying to sell remaining apartments
• Vision - developer in bankruptcy situation - unclear if this will proceed, and if so, in what form
• Trilogy - on hold
• Meriton's Soliel - under construction
• Meriton's Herschel Street highrise - advertised by Meriton as coming soon
• Devine's Hamilton Harbour - not in inner city - construction to commence January 2010, maybe Devine's last apartment project in Brisbane
• Rive at Breakfast Creek - construction commencing
• Waters Edge at West End - first stage: ground works commencing
• Riverpoint at West End - first stage under construction
  
• Code at Bowen Hills
• Multiplex's Promenade at the Hamilton shipping terminal
• Mirvac's Waterfront at Newstead
• Macrossan Towers, under construction, one apartment per floor
• Yungaba at Kangaroo Point, about to start pre-sales in the next month
• Mosaic, in the Valley, in presales

Brisbane

"Meanwhile recent investor confidence has buoyed Brisbane's luxury apartment market, according to analysts."

"Development group Pradella has sold 73 per cent of the 54 apartments off the plan at West End development Waters Edge."

Brisbane Times

"However, the forces affecting Brisbane are similar to Melbourne but the Gold Coast has an apartment oversupply. Both Melbourne and Brisbane are feeding on the fact that Sydney dwellings are just too expensive and the shortage is making the situation worse."

Business Spectator

Water's Edge Progressing But Slowly

Pradella reports as follows:
"Waters Edge has received a fantastic response since its October launch late last year and has now achieved 50 sales in total to date. Despite the uncertain times, investors are regaining confidence and returning to the property market. Waters Edge, located on the river at West End, is testament to this with 2 apartments sold within the last week, with a further 3 expressions of interest obtained."

Water's Edge Update

From a Pradella newletter:
"Despite Brisbane's uncertain property market, buyer confidence remains strong for Waters Edge with an unprecented $40 million in sales made since its launch. Forty-eight of the 221 apartments have sold to a mix of investors and owner-occupiers, as buyers look to quickly capitalise by purchasing at the unique site."

"Consisting of two eight-storey buildings, named Drift and Reach, one, two and three bedroom apartments are available, priced from $540,000.In addition to the apartments, there are 32 premium absolute riverfrontage apartments called the Riverfront Collection that have a total area of between 188-332m2, consist of 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms plus a separate multi-purpose room and study, priced from $1.795 million are for buyers searching for the ultimate in inner-city luxury living."

Waters Edge on the Edge

A friend forwarded an email to me, recently received from Pradella, that included the following:

"Pradella have adjusted the pricing of some of the apartments in ‘Reach’ at Waters Edge. We have now sold 50 apartments, but we need to keep moving toward our pre sales targets, hence the pricing adjustments. The 1 beds have not been adjusted, but some of the 2 bed plus 1 bath, and 2 bed plus 2 bath have, and there are some very good buys to be had."

My guess is that no construction will commence until there are about 100 pre-sales.

Water's Edge at West End Update

A friend forwarded an email to me, recently received from Pradella, that included the following:

"Pradella have adjusted the pricing of some of the apartments in ‘Reach’ at Waters Edge. We have now sold 50 apartments, but we need to keep moving toward our pre sales targets, hence the pricing adjustments. The 1 beds have not been adjusted, but some of the 2 bed plus 1 bath, and 2 bed plus 2 bath have, and there are some very good buys to be had."

My guess is that no construction will commence until there are about 100 pre-sales.